Category Archives: Wakefield

Will Patrick Holford Be Calling Upon His Mailing List to Sign the New Andrew Wakefield Petition? If So, We’ve Made Some Annotations

In June 2007, as the Autism Omnibus Hearings were in progress and the initial test case was being heard, Patrick Holford contacted his mailing list and asked them to sign a petition in support of Dr Andrew Wakefield. Although it doesn’t look like he ever signed the petition, it is clear that he influenced other people to sign, people who directly cited him as instrumental in the decision not to vaccinate children against preventable diseases.

Dr Carmel O’Donovan, Andrew Wakefield’s wife, recently emailed around asking for signatures in support of him. However, it seems that there is another petition, this one grandiosely and desperately asking people to sign up to We Support Andy Wakefield (Tiny URL’d). Age of Autism rather half-heartedly just reproduces the blusterous call for an enquiry (Tiny URL’d) and, without any trace of irony, condemns “the censorship of science” and the competence of Brian Deer in his remarkable investigative journalism.

We offer an annotated version of the petition: all links have been added by us and our text additions are in italics. Continue reading

20 Comments

Filed under Andrew Wakefield, autism, autistic spectrum disorders, brian deer, measles, MMR, patrick holford, vaccination, vaccines, Wakefield

Patrick Holford Promotes Error: Does This Explain His Continuing Support for Opposing MMR and Supporting Andrew Wakefield’s Research?

Patrick Holford on ITV Lunchtime 16 April 2008
Former Visiting Professor Patrick Holford has such a sensitive moral barometer that he is constantly pointing out his perception of the failings of actual researchers and scientists and questioning their integrity. Operating in this parallel world that he does (see Part 1 and Part 2), perhaps it is not surprising that he continues to avoid issuing an update on what the findings from the Autism Omnibus and the stark revelations of the fraud and deliberate manipulation that underpins Dr Andrew Wakfield’s research means for his marketing and promotion of unevidenced diagnostic tests and diet strategies for the ‘treatment’ of autism (assessed here).

You may remember Patrick Holford’s keen support for Andrew Wakefield and his research (see, also, Patrick Holford and Andrew Wakefield’s Discredited Findings: Part 1 and Part 2). we have previously noted that Holford espouses support for Wakefield and his research allows some entrepreneurs to sell unevidenced diagnostic tests (both Wakefield and Holford continue to support the use of Secretin despite not only the absence of efficacy but the indication that it may be less efficacious than a saltwater placebo), promote consultation for difficult-to-follow diets and sell supplements. Continue reading

7 Comments

Filed under Andrew Wakefield, autism, autistic spectrum disorders, brian deer, gluten- and casein-free diet, heavy metal toxicity, IgG tests, immunization, measles, mercury, MMR, patrick holford, supplements, thimerosal, thiomersal, vaccination, vaccines, Wakefield

Ben Goldacre on BBC 1’s One Show

Ben Goldacre BBC One Show September 8 2008.

Ben Goldacre BBC One Show September 8 2008.

Dr Ben Goldacre was on BBC 1’s One Show. Watch out for it on BBC iPlayer for September 8 (from 8:10 to 12:00 or thereabouts if you crave the added wisdom of Len Goodman). [Update, please use the iPlayer link if you can because this tells the BBC that you were interested in the Bad Science segment. For those who can’t, or for when it disappears, there is a YouTube.]

In an action-packed segment that serves as a lively precis of his book, Goldacre admonished the media for their poor science coverage and then took the viewer on a rapid tour of the Media Hall of Shame for Science Reporting and Obsession with Miracle Cures. Continue reading

10 Comments

Filed under Ben Goldacre, supplements, Wakefield

Patrick Holford and Andrew Wakefield’s Discredited Findings: Part 2

Professor Patrick Holford of Teesside University is a staunch supporter of Dr Andrew Wakefield and in 2007 set out his case as to why others should likewise support Wakefield. Holford has updated his website to explore the issue: Patrick Holford’s Concerns About the MMR Vaccine.

Patrick Holford claims to have remarkable insight into the causation of autism and how to “bring them back” when children are on the autistic spectrum. He suggests that there is hard evidence that links MMR and autism. Continue reading

15 Comments

Filed under Andrew Wakefield, autism, autistic spectrum disorders, immunization, measles, MMR, vaccination, vaccines, Wakefield

Patrick Holford and Andrew Wakefield’s Discredited Findings: Part 1

Professor Patrick Holford of Teesside University and Head of Science and Education at Biocare frequently upbraids professionals and researchers for what he perceives as their lack of up-to-date research.

Yet, it was with an extraordinary sense of deja woo that we learned about Patrick Holford’s Concerns About the MMR Vaccine. Continue reading

10 Comments

Filed under Andrew Wakefield, autistic spectrum disorders, brian deer, Holford, immunization, measles, MMR, patrick holford, Wakefield

Wakefield will not be “struck off for…challenging the status quo”; in other news, bear defecates in the woods

22I wasn’t at all sure if I wanted to post this. I’m with Dr Crippen in being less than happy about the additional publicity going to the ‘evidence’ that MMR causes autism. However, I think it’s worth returning to Holford’s claim that “Dr Andrew Wakefield…is facing a hearing with the General Medical Council, and may be struck off for, in effect, challenging the status quo”. With Wakefield’s GMC hearing coming up, these issues will get a lot of publicity anyway…

Holford’s claims was not just wrong – it was very predictably wrong (I predicted it, not that I’d expect any credit for predicting something this obvious). The GMC has now released its charges against Wakefield – challenging the status quo is, unsurprisingly, not among them. Continue reading

3 Comments

Filed under autism, MMR, patrick holford, Wakefield

Patrick Holford and Andrew Wakefield

The correspondences between Patrick Holford and Dr Andrew Wakefield are extraordinary. Even leaving aside the fact that Patrick Holford recently emailed a large number of people, asking them to sign a petition in support of Andrew Wakefield (albeit the first few times that I checked after this email, Patrick Holford and his name are conspicuous by their absence). They both regard themselves as prophets who are without honour in their own country. Read remainder of entry

7 Comments

Filed under Andrew Wakefield, autism, autistic spectrum disorders, Holford, measles, MMR, patrick holford, Wakefield

Patrick Holford, Glutamine and Autism

Patrick Holford frequently advises people to heal their gut with the use of glutamine. He particularly recommends the value of glutamine for gut-healing in children on the autistic spectrum.

Restoring a healthy gut by supplementing digestive enzymes and probiotics is known to produce positive results in autistic children. The amino acid glutamine is especially important in restoring the integrity of the digestive tract. Drinking 5g dissolved in water just before bedtime can help heal the gut.
[Emphasis added.]

Some version of that advice appears in a number of the Holford books and websites. Oddly enough, the advice on this topic on Food for the Brain (FFTB) has been modified to indicate that glutamine may be contra-indicated with children with ASD (autistic spectrum disorders), but Holford has yet to update any of his other writings to reflect those changes. Read on for more

5 Comments

Filed under Andrew Wakefield, autism, autistic spectrum disorders, Food for the brain, glutamine, Holford, patrick holford, Wakefield

Patrick Holford Believes That He Is More Knowledgeable Than the BDA?

Patrick Holford and his Magic Answers have come to Dr Crippen’s attention recently: mostly because of Holford’s:

claims to enable people to say “no” to cancer, arthritis and heart disease.

And diabetes. It seems that Patrick Holford and other nutritional therapists who claim that doctors have no interest in nutritional or lifestyle approaches to health problems are wrong. Read on for more

4 Comments

Filed under Andrew Wakefield, BDA, British Dietetic Association, catherine collins, Dunning, Holford, Kruger, patrick holford, Wakefield

Patrick Holford Encourages You to "Say No" to Cancer

Patrick Holford makes more remarkable claims than Holford Watch can keep up with so we are grateful to Dr. Crippen for tackling the issue of Holford’s claims for cancer. Pay £6.99 to say “no” to cancer also expresses Dr. Crippen’s disappointment at learning of Patrick Holford and his support for the discredited findings of Dr. Andrew Wakefield.

Several people have expressed their disappointment about Patrick Holford and his support for unusual or discredited theories. There has even been literary speculation as to whether Patrick Holford is akin to a contemporary Doctor Knock.

Kevin Leitch on Andrew Wakefield and the death of the MMR debacle and
Justice for Katie
Mike Stanton on Patrick Holford and his unusual views on vaccination, MMR and autism
Patrick Holford and Dr Andrew Wakefield’s Discredited Findings: Part 1
Patrick Holford and Dr Andrew Wakefield’s Discredited Findings: Part 2
Patrick Holford Claims Remarkable Benefits for Homeopathic Vaccinations

Holford Watch has a number of posts about Patrick Holford and his support for Dr. Andrew Wakefield.

Leave a comment

Filed under Andrew Wakefield, autism, Holford, measles, MMR, patrick holford, vaccination, Wakefield